Blog

Wed Mar 05 2025

How to work with Shopify themes: A complete guide

Art

Choosing the right Shopify theme is one of the most important decisions for your online store. The right theme sets the tone for your store–defines the user experience, showcases your brand identity and ensures everything works smoothly. In this guide, we'll explore the different types of Shopify themes, where to find them, the advantages and risks of using different themes and best practices for implementing a new theme successfully.

What is a Shopify theme?

A Shopify theme defines your online store's design, layout and overall user experience. It controls the appearance and functionality of your store, from the homepage to the checkout process. You can find both free and paid themes from Shopify and third-party developers.

Where to find Shopify themes

When selecting a Shopify theme, you have three primary options:

1. Shopify theme store

2. Third-party theme marketplaces

3. Independent developers

Shopify theme comparison: Official vs. third-party

When you're choosing between an official Shopify theme or a third-party theme, there are several factors you should consider.

Shopify official theme Third-party theme
Security Fully vetted and secure Potential security risks
Support Direct Shopify or trusted developer support Varies by developer
Updates Guaranteed compatibility with new Shopify features Updates may be inconsistent
Customization Limited but stable Often highly customizable but may require coding
Price Typically more expensive More variety in pricing
Compatibility All are built for Shopify 2.0 May not be compatible with Shopify 2.0

One theme to rule them all–Dawn

Shopify provides a set of free themes, but they are all variations of the same core theme—Dawn. Dawn is the default theme for new stores. While Shopify has released other free themes like Trade, Spotlight, Craft, etc., these themes share nearly identical code and functionality. The primary difference lies in their default settings and preset design choices.

If you're already using Dawn and considering switching to another free theme from Shopify, don't bother. You can achieve the same visual effects simply by adjusting the settings in the theme editor.

Risks of using unofficial Shopify themes

Go to any Shopify online community or local group, and you'll find questions and real-life struggles with themes. Most of the issues are with third-party custom themes. A logo won't appear correctly. The merchant lost contact with the developer. Other updates to the store made the cart stop working. And so on and so on.

While third-party themes can be more affordable and offer unique designs, they also come with some risks.

1. Security vulnerabilities

2. Compatibility issues

3. Limited or no support

When it's time to change your Shopify theme

There are many situations where you'll want to update or switch your Shopify theme. If you're on the fence, here are some key scenarios where you might just want to try out a different theme:

1. Rebranding or major store overhaul

2. Performance and speed issues

3. Compatibility with Shopify 2.0

4. Adding new features

5. Temporary theme changes for promotions

A must-remember whenever you switch themes

When you switch themes, some of your webshop content will automatically transfer and some you will have to manually move. This is because some shop content is stored within the Shopify admin and some inside the theme. When changing themes, you'll need to copy over any content stored inside the theme to the new one.

Content stored in Shopify admin

Content in the Shopify admin remains even when you change themes. This includes:

Content stored in Shopify theme

Content that you added from the theme editor is part of the theme. That means you'll need to manually copy and paste this information when changing themes, including:

Best practices for implementing a Shopify theme

Congrats! You've decided on the theme for your store. Whether you've chosen a theme from Shopify's marketplace, or one from a third-party, follow our checklist to help make the process as easy as possible.

What are you waiting for? Go find your next theme

Shopify themes play a critical role in shaping your store's user experience. While third-party themes can be tempting due to lower costs and unique designs, they come with potential risks related to security, support and updates. If you choose to explore an unofficial Shopify theme, follow best practices to minimize risks and help make it as error-free as possible. Ultimately, the right theme balances aesthetics, functionality, security and long-term stability.